Friday, December 2, 2011

Letter to the Leaves: We as English Majors


I want to make it known that as an English major, I at times feel as an outsider. All too often in my classes do I hear how he's been reading books since he’s been in middle school, or how they've got this published or that published. I see how some of my fellow classmates use knowledge as social currency and think that they are wealthier then someone who is less able to present their self in the written word.

As English majors, we have to acknowledge that we view education differently than others.

Because so much of our worth is intangible, we are quick to defend it at all costs. We have put so much time and effort into reading and acquiring this motivation for self-education that we forget that not everyone has this.

In the sciences, people expect the instructor to tell them the right answer. This is expected because most if not all of the time there is only ONE right answer. It is as simple as "put this in, get this out". Tests are multiple-choice and leave no room for the self.

English isn't like that. All we have to do is justify our ideas with a few lines from the text and we arrive at a correct answer (thus we are all critics with our own critical theory; We create this critical theory, from our sense of self). We have all had that kid in class who is way off base, but the teacher still gives him a pat on the back.

He gets that pat on the back because in English there is partial credit. We reward effort.

Sciences do not. It’s all or nothing. And with all this emphasis on the correct answer, the end, why is it so surprising to you instructors that this is your students’ main concern.

We as a society have shifted from transcending Emerson to deifying Einstein.

We live in a world of instant gratification.

To call your students "idiotic", "stupid" or "unmotivated" is superficial. You are criticizing the effect and not the cause.

But Bermuda, it’s not a lack of ability. These students are not mindless robots programmed by society. They can still choose to make an attempt. You see Bermuda, all it is a lack of effort.

Yeah, I agree. It’s totally a lack of effort and not a lack of ability for most students. But you see that’s where you instructors come in. You have the toughest job of all because you have to reverse this social norm. You have to inspire your students to want to better their self for more than a piece of paper.

But you must understand that genuine inspiration cannot be given, but must be fostered.

No one should be in a position to instruct if they cannot put aside their self-wealth to see the promise each student has. It is your job to show these students the relevance writing and reading have for their lives.

Now, there are always going to be people who just go to college to get a piece of paper. But those are going to be the same people who go through life as a means to an end.

They will never know the beauty of a sunrise, the soothing echo of the ocean waves, or the invigorating power of mountain air.

And even this is not the greatest tragedy. A tragedy more egregious, is their loss of self-reliance.

People are no longer reliant on themselves as they once were for knowledge. We are slowly losing that aspect as more and more of our society becomes Google-able.

But as English majors, this is our duty to the world:

To show the rest, the relevance of writing, the importance of reading, and most of all,

The beauty inherent in the self.

Undoubtedly Yours,
Bermuda

4 comments:

  1. Do you agree that it is also an instructor's job to hold his students accountable and to expect from them and foster in them a level of the self-reliance that our culture has not?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Yes I do

    "But you see that’s where you instructors come in. You have the toughest job of all because you have to reverse this social norm. You have to inspire your students to want to better their self for more than a piece of paper.

    But you must understand that genuine inspiration cannot be given, but must be fostered."

    ReplyDelete
  3. What I'm asking was not yet addressed in your blog: how much of this inspiration is fosterable and how much is going to be dependent on what the individual student is willing to bring to the table?

    ReplyDelete
  4. I think the section in your new blog where you talk about your counselor hints at this very question.

    I think that:

    the instructor is the path, and it is the students responsibility to take the first step, and then another, and another....

    Percentage wise, instructor 10% Student 90% (+/- 10) haha

    ReplyDelete